Looking for Feedback on a new subscription box service

orionfield Apr 9, 2017

  1. orionfield

    orionfield TrainBoard Member

    276
    22
    14
    I am starting a new subscription box service for scale modelers, and I was thinking about including some model railroad boxes. I would love some feedback about how much people would be willing to spend per month, and what people would expect in the box each month.

    Off the top of my head, I would offer a box with some passenger or freight car kits, along with some paints and decals, for those of us with some model building experience. I would also allow you to select the scale of your choice.

    If I offered boxes with ready to roll cars, what would you be expecting?

    I can't wait to see what you think.
     
  2. BoxcabE50

    BoxcabE50 HOn30 & N Scales Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    67,667
    23,131
    653
    Interesting. Been thinking.... But likely as I am in HOn30 mostly these days, not something which would be a fit for me? If I could afford to commit to anything steady.
     
  3. orionfield

    orionfield TrainBoard Member

    276
    22
    14
    Yeah, I don't know if that would be possible, maybe N and HO, but I have always wanted to do N scale narrow gauge, so anything is possible. In a hypothetical world that I did offer an HOn30 box, what would you like to see in it?
     
    LocoHorn likes this.
  4. Rocket Jones

    Rocket Jones TrainBoard Member

    783
    601
    18
    Interesting idea. I've seen some pretty cool subscription boxes... must give this some thought.
     
  5. orionfield

    orionfield TrainBoard Member

    276
    22
    14
    Great! Let me know!
     
  6. BoxcabE50

    BoxcabE50 HOn30 & N Scales Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    67,667
    23,131
    653
    Would these be plastic, resin or wooden laser? Resin kits for some Maine 2F (HOn30 in scale) proto cars. Box, flat, gondola, etc. But the material is just a pain to assemble. I will grant to you that those are better than nothing. But... Wooden laser exist for box cars as well. Nice, but a bit pricey.

    There is a fellow who has bashed a Tichy HO wooden hopper to HOn30. Looks great. That car I wish could be had in a commercial package.

    I believe the primary issue could be having enough rolling stock variety to sustain such an effort in HOn30.
     
  7. acptulsa

    acptulsa TrainBoard Member

    3,370
    5,987
    75
    You'd have better luck, I suspect, if you further subdivided by era. Transition Era modelers won't be any more pleased to get Ten Packs this month than Modern Era modelers would be to get an ice reefer next month...
     
  8. orionfield

    orionfield TrainBoard Member

    276
    22
    14
    Sure, that can be easily done. As far as what people would get every month, in addition to models, I want to include detail parts, maybe some generic scenery stuff, tools, paints, generic decals, maybe some pins or buttons people could wear. But the main selling point is going to be exclusive products that you can only get through the service.

    There will also be an exchange, where people can trade in what they don't want for something else.
     
  9. orionfield

    orionfield TrainBoard Member

    276
    22
    14
    Sorry to double post, but here is where we're at so far:

    In the subscription process, you will be able to choose: Scale, Era (19th century, Early 20th Century, Transition Era, Modern), Region (Northeast, Southeast, Midwest, Northwest, Southwest), Setting (Rural, Urban), Skill Level (Ready to Roll only, Modeling skills required)

    Each Box would potentially contain 1 or two cars (Depending on scale) or a locomotive conversion, related details (Loads, wheels, couplers, Resin parts, Photo etch, etc), accessories (decals, paints, tools, etc), railroad related pins or buttons.

    I will be partnering with various manufacturers from across the industry for exclusive products

    The Exchange: If you don't like what you get, trade it in for something else.

    It doesn't have to be a mystery, we can let you know what you'll be getting before we send things out, so that you make your exchange before shipping.
     
  10. mhampton

    mhampton TrainBoard Member

    224
    2
    24
    What is your target price for your subscription?
     
  11. orionfield

    orionfield TrainBoard Member

    276
    22
    14
    Thats the million dollar question...I wont know that until I secure my suppliers and know the wholesale costs of each item, I would love to keep it under $30 if I can.
     
  12. Shortround

    Shortround TrainBoard Member

    4,412
    5,282
    93
    I may be interested if things sound good when you get it figured out. I'm into the transition era in Wisconsin. I had to move so I don't have a layout yet. But do have a steam switcher and 4-6-0 small streamer (DCC with sound) two ice boxes, a half passenger/half freight car and six flat cars to haul the logs to the paper factory. All in HO.
     
    Last edited: Apr 12, 2017
  13. Mr. Trainiac

    Mr. Trainiac TrainBoard Member

    1,546
    2,160
    46
    Would I have to subscribe for, say, a year, or could I buy an individual box if it had a car I liked?
     

Share This Page