dumb question from a newbie

beast5420 Aug 22, 2002

  1. beast5420

    beast5420 TrainBoard Member

    760
    37
    28
    Is there a good way to distinguish a dash 9 from like a SD 90 from a distance? I know that both are 6 axle locos and both have the overhanging radiator (fan housings). But is there something else? Is there a book or something that has a breakdown on doing model IDs with pictures??????? Thanks!!!!

    [ 22. August 2002, 14:46: Message edited by: beast5420 ]
     
  2. Martyn Read

    Martyn Read TrainBoard Supporter

    1,990
    0
    33
    From the front the cab & nose shape is different, on the GE's the angled down section is sort of triangular and angled down to the nose corner, and on the EMD standard nose it's almost rectangular and slopes to the side, unless it's one of them phaseII SD90's with the "beaten with an ugly stick" mess of a nose!

    (Note, the GE's share the cab shape with dash 8's / AC4400's / AC6000's and the EMD's share the cab shape with late SD60M / SD70M / SD75M / SD70I / SD70MACs etc...so identifying the cab shape to EMD or GE won't tie it down to one model, but it will tell you wether it's a GE or EMD product)

    From the side or rear, the 90MAC's have a large extended section of body behind the angled radiator which has the dynamic brakes in it, the dash 9's end basically at the radiator, so the 90MAC is much longer!

    [ 22. August 2002, 15:06: Message edited by: Martyn Read ]
     
  3. beast5420

    beast5420 TrainBoard Member

    760
    37
    28
    thanks martyn!!!

    do you (or anyone else) have any idea of a book???
     
  4. watash

    watash Passed away March 7, 2010 TrainBoard Supporter In Memoriam

    4,826
    20
    64
    Try: SIMMONS-BOARDMAN BOOKS, INC.
    The Railway Educational Bureau
    1809 Capitol Ave.
    Omaha, Nebraska 68102

    phones
    ordering: 1-800-228-9670
    fax: 402-346-1783

    web site: www.transelert.com

    email: orders@sb-reb.com

    Look under Locomotives for the real railroad engine manuals, etc.

    Also check the Kalmbach book lists in the Model Railroader mag. for the "Diesel Spotter's Guide" if still in print.
     
  5. watash

    watash Passed away March 7, 2010 TrainBoard Supporter In Memoriam

    4,826
    20
    64
    Beast5420

    EBAY has a Diesel Spotter's Guide on Buy it Now for $25.00 (no bids yet at $15.00)
    Item # 1761 306 050

    [​IMG]

    [ 31. August 2002, 07:52: Message edited by: watash ]
     
  6. Charlie

    Charlie TrainBoard Member

    1,911
    185
    39
    Welcome aboard beast5420,

    but let me gently chide you; never feel that
    any question you ask is "dumb". We ask
    questions to obtain knowledge. How can that
    be dumb?
    keep askin' questions, somebody is bound to
    have an answer here. Glad to have you as a
    member

    CT
     
  7. Pete

    Pete TrainBoard Member

    257
    1
    19
    It's easy to distinguish between GE's and EMD's simply by the fuek tank. The GE's are angular, and the EMD's are rounded. Another good book is "A Field Guide to Trains" by Gerald Foster. Houghton Mifflin Company publishers. Welcome to Trainboard!
     
  8. beast5420

    beast5420 TrainBoard Member

    760
    37
    28
    thanks everyone. i'll do some snooping around and see if ebay or amazon still have any of those books. thanks much!
     

Share This Page