"G scale" forum 1-22.5 Misnomer ??

Davy Mac Aug 11, 2002

  1. Davy Mac

    Davy Mac E-Mail Bounces

    34
    0
    16
    Hi guys,
    the "G"scale? forum name is a bit misleading. there are umpteen different scales fall within the orbit of G .Not just 1.22.5
    Can I suggest that the forum be re-named as "Garden scales" . Folks who are not into G probably don't appreciate the differences between the various garden scales. Can I suggest that either each outdoor scale has it's own forum like G /1/29th, G1/32nd etc or simply rename the forum "Garden scales"
    The scale issue is a bit of a hotbed of discussion these days within the garden fraternity.To draw a comparison it's like there was an "HOForum" but it really represented
    HO ,OO,HOn3 etc.,etc.,. Just a suggestion guys but important to some of us "Garden" modellers . All the best Davy
     
  2. Alan

    Alan Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    10,798
    460
    127
    Hi Davey, I think the title Garden Scales, or maybe Larger Scales, would be a good idea. This could encompass everything above HO.
     
  3. Tom Farin

    Tom Farin New Member

    8
    0
    15
    Hi Davy,

    My vote is for Large Scale rather than Garden scale. The last GR featured an outdoor layout executed in O. And I've seen plenty of large scale modular and indoor layouts.

    Garden indicates where the layout is located.

    Large scale generally represents 1:20.3, 1:22.5, 1;24, 1:29, and 1:32. Whew -- did I get them all? Hopefully someday it will all get whittled down to 1:20.3 for 3.0 foot narrow gauge and either 1:29 or 1:32 for standard gauge.

    Tom
     
  4. Davy Mac

    Davy Mac E-Mail Bounces

    34
    0
    16
    Hi Alan and Tom,
    Tom you are probably right,
    Large Scales probably would be better or even
    "Large and Garden" Scales would be even more appropriate ??
    Whatever as Toms list of scales illustrates it's not as simple or correct to describe G as
    1-22.5. , it's only part of the story.
    Thanks guys DAVY
     

Share This Page