What engines is N missing most?

Kevin M Aug 14, 2007

  1. Caddy58

    Caddy58 TrainBoard Member

    972
    94
    26
    I want smaller steam that was still used up to the transition ear.

    0-6-0 Switchers: The 0-8-0 will be great for main classification yards, but samller switchers were used in smaller yards, industry switching and transfer runs.

    4-6-0 (Modern): They were light enough to be used on most trackage, so on some roads (like the NP) the lived longer than heavy mainline engines who were replaced by diesels.

    4-8-4 Northen variants: The available Northerns are not really satisfying for the majority of modellers:
    Bachman 484: Technology is dated and uses disk drivers
    CC 484 S2: Huge driver diameter (80"), so not rewally usable for anything else
    Bachman J: Tiny drivers, so not usable for anything else...

    A great choice for a Northern could be the Timken 1111 "Four Aces", built by ALCO in 1930. Though it was a one of a kind engine, is was test run on 14 different railroads to prove the concept of roller bearings on driving axles.
    The roads include:
    New York Central
    Pennsylvania
    C&O
    Erie
    New York, New Haven & Hartford
    Boston & Maine
    D&H
    Delaware, Lackawana & Western
    Lehigh Valley
    Nickel Plate
    Chicago & Alton
    Missouri Pacific
    CB&Q
    NP

    It was considered a very handsome engine, plus it was purchased by the NP and used as Class A1, number 2626 until 1957.




    [​IMG]

    But decorated as 1111, with the script "Timken" on the tender and 4 playing card symbols on the numberboards it would be correct for 14 roads :))

    Cheers
    Dirk
     
  2. BNSF16

    BNSF16 TrainBoard Member

    42
    0
    12
    If wishes were horses, kitbashers would have to find something new to try.

    My wish list

    Diesel,
    1) GP60M / GP60B
    2) New run of Kato BNSF corrected C44-9W (4 side window cab) H2 & BNSF Warbonnet
    3) GP60
    4) GP50
    5) C40-8/C40-8W
    6) SW1500

    Mechanism preffered - Atlas 4 axle, Kato 6 axle.

    Steam

    1) Pennsy J1 2-10-4 (just because I like them)
    2) Some extra tenders for heritage trains (ie UP ex turbine type)
    3) UP FEF 4-8-4 (I reckon athearn will have this comming in the next few years)
    4) Redone LL Berks with either more weight or tractions tyres, DCC & sound.
     
  3. tgromek

    tgromek TrainBoard Member

    164
    7
    22

    That's funny, I need the sisters also.
     
  4. Sizemore

    Sizemore TrainBoard Supporter

    611
    68
    26
    My list:
    Steam
    4-4-0 American (CW era, that's SCALE)
    4-8-4 Northern (Common driver, boiler, although I'd settle for C&O 614)

    Diesel
    AS-16 or DRS 4-4-15
     
  5. Kozmo

    Kozmo TrainBoard Member

    708
    0
    18
    I'm all for Kato making:
    Both the Hiawatha F7 4-6-4 Hudson & 4-4-2 Atlantic streamlined steamers
    and with complete matching passenger car sets.
     
  6. Triplex

    Triplex TrainBoard Member

    3,214
    1
    44
    SD40-2 and GP38-2, Phase III versions (angled blower housing). Mostly useful for CP/SOO.

    Anything at all with a Canadian safety cab.

    Any heavy electrics.
     
  7. dave n

    dave n TrainBoard Supporter

    2,107
    231
    35
    BNSF16 -- Oh yea, I forgot about the GP60M & 60B! I wonder is Life Like is ever going to release more GP60s? They did a great job on that model I think -- it would be awesome if they released some more road numbers and even better if they surprised us with the M and or B!!
     
  8. SteamDonkey74

    SteamDonkey74 TrainBoard Supporter

    7,160
    171
    90
    The new HO Hiawatha set has one of my NTrak club members openly considering switching scales.
     
  9. brokemoto

    brokemoto TrainBoard Member

    1,687
    760
    45
    A 'modern', higher drivered (sixty eight inches or more) ten-wheeler.

    A nineteenth century ten-wheeler

    A USRA heavy pacific

    A decently operating nineteenth century eight-wheeler (sorry, B-mann's needs much improvement)

    USRA light pacific that is better than MP's

    USRA light mikado that is better than MP's

    A twelve-wheeler

    A decapod

    A prairie

    A Baldwin road switcher (must have a token diseasel).

    Oh, and did I mention that N scale needed a higher drivered ten-wheeler?
     
  10. MRL

    MRL TrainBoard Member

    1,406
    14
    25
    What is needed is old stuff, C30's, SD45's, U30's,etc.

    We have the older units already made instead of a ACe or something, eventhough I am dying for one (a bunch), Take the old units like a tunnel motor or a switch engine and paint them in modern railroad schemes like with all the leasing companies, Progress Rail, LTEX, FURX, etc. Maybe do units in a rivate scheme like for grain elevators or other companies, Cargill GP9, ADM SW something.
    maybe some mexican railroads.
    What's needed is some short lines. maybe.
    Well that's about it for now until I think of more for another spur of the moment typing as fast as I can frenzy.
     
  11. JKD

    JKD TrainBoard Member

    472
    5
    14
    Thought of one more that someone (probably Kato please or someone who does replacement shells) should do.

    SD70MAC with flared radiator.
     
  12. Chad Cowan

    Chad Cowan TrainBoard Member

    224
    35
    14
    I'll be in the minority here...but an Atlas ALCO C-636 would be a GREAT addition.
     
  13. bryan9

    bryan9 TrainBoard Member

    368
    11
    14
    GE 44 tonner

    Glad to see this mentioned.

    These little beauties were owned by a huge variety of roads as well as a variety of lineside industries. It adds a lot of operating potential to be able to put one or two of these at work in a lineside industry, such as a coal tipple or grain silo. From the Model Railways Shunting Puzzles website (highly recommended), here's a nice photo of a Bachmann HO 44 tonner in action:

    [​IMG]

    --Bryan
     
  14. BNSF FAN

    BNSF FAN TrainBoard Supporter

    10,077
    30,386
    153
    I would like to see:

    SDP40F
    GP60M
    GP60B
    DD35 A & B units
    More EMD switchers - both sw's and nw's
    SD50F
    SD60F
     
  15. CHARGER

    CHARGER TrainBoard Member

    947
    71
    25
    1. ALCO S-1, S-2s
    2. EMD SW1500's
    3. GE U30B's

    How about a locomotive that can run on almost any layout with a theme after 1950's. Prototypically correct for US and European layouts. Locomotive type was built by BOTH ALCO and EMD satisfying hard core brand loyalists. The type can be found in many varied paint schemes across the country on numerous shortlines and tourist roads. Can operate on standard and narrow guage track. What you say, this type of locomotive does not exist............

    The ALCO/EMD MRS-1!
    Initially built for the Navy, Air Force and I'll take mine in US Army black and gold. ;)
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Aug 23, 2007
  16. Bob Morris

    Bob Morris TrainBoard Supporter

    748
    0
    19
    There's such a great selection now, I'm having trouble keeping the budget under control ;-)

    The new heavy 4-8-2 about to be released should be a great addition. I'd also love to see some traction tire axles available for the Bachmann 2-6-6-2. This beautiful, albeit, anemic puller could be a GREAT engine with a traction tire option (like Kato's Mikado).

    I will add my enthusiastic "me too!" for a modern 4-6-0 and 4-4-2. I'm very appreciative of Model Power's 4-4-0 and 2-6-0 offerings and would like to see some more (with traction tires).
     
  17. keystonecrossings

    keystonecrossings TrainBoard Member

    358
    0
    20
    Every year my PRR-talk mailing list/Keystone Crossing web site polls PRR modelers for their top three desires in each of many categories. In November 2006, the N scale top desires were:

    STEAM:
    1. H8s / H9s / H10s 2-8-0 Consolidations
    2. K4s 4-6-2 Pacifics
    3. I1sa 2-10-0 Decapod

    ELECTRIC:
    1. P5 series
    2. GG1 [Pre-announced by Kato]
    3. E44

    DIESEL:
    1. BP20 Baldwin DR 6-4-20 "Passenger Shark"
    2. BP60 / BH50 Baldwin DR 12-8-30 "Centipede"
    3. BS24m Baldwin RT-624 centercab

    Not on the above list, but one I sorely feel the need for, is the EMD SW1. However, with DCC and tractive effort mandatory, we all know why we don't have these yet!
     
  18. BnO_Hendo

    BnO_Hendo TrainBoard Member

    225
    0
    17
    Who's releasing a new 4-8-2? Must've missed it.
     
  19. ErnieC

    ErnieC TrainBoard Member

    50
    0
    13
    Simple question, easy answer: Ten-Wheeler (4-6-0), Nn3 Shay
    PLEASE!
    Ernie C
     
  20. Bob Morris

    Bob Morris TrainBoard Supporter

    748
    0
    19
    Walthers/Life-Like is releasing a Heavy Mountain (see Wig-Wag's site for details). DCC factory installed too.
     

Share This Page